{
  "$schema": "https://zachshallbetter.com/claims.json",
  "method": "CompInt Scientific Project Audit and Grading Standard v0.1.0-draft (self-audit; draft standard, not independent validation)",
  "thesis_critical_threshold": 0.7,
  "maturity": "M2–M3 (coherent formalization, partially instrumented; NOT empirically validated)",
  "grade": {
    "fatal_gates": "all pass (G=1)",
    "numeric_as_validated_science": 40.9,
    "letter": "F as validated science; credible-to-strong for its M2–M3 stage",
    "verdict": "Reframe + Revise"
  },
  "audit": "https://zachshallbetter.com/methodology",
  "claims": [
    {
      "id": "C1",
      "text": "Model, state, and semantics are separated from projection and representation.",
      "type": "definitional/formal",
      "evidence": "contract.ts as single source of truth; archive ↔ \"dumb renderer\"; engine render-modes",
      "support": 0.78,
      "thesis_critical": true,
      "verdict": "supported"
    },
    {
      "id": "C2",
      "text": "The site emits multiple governed projections of one underlying model.",
      "type": "descriptive/formal",
      "evidence": "/projections.json declares 8 projections against the 12-field Projection Contract",
      "support": 0.74,
      "thesis_critical": true,
      "verdict": "supported"
    },
    {
      "id": "C3",
      "text": "Coupling is instantiated as reciprocal constraint, not a one-way effect.",
      "type": "descriptive",
      "evidence": "engine: elements bend the field and the field bends them back; feedback channels",
      "support": 0.72,
      "thesis_critical": false,
      "verdict": "supported"
    },
    {
      "id": "C4",
      "text": "The generated meaning layer is attributed evidence, not unattributed assertion.",
      "type": "descriptive",
      "evidence": "data.generated {at, model, sources, fields, validation}",
      "support": 0.68,
      "thesis_critical": false,
      "verdict": "below-threshold: attributed, but per-claim uncertainty is coarse"
    },
    {
      "id": "C5",
      "text": "The system does not infer comprehension, belief, or identity.",
      "type": "normative/scope",
      "evidence": "/methodology non-claims; no analytics or behavioral tracking; salted ip_hash only",
      "support": 0.82,
      "thesis_critical": true,
      "verdict": "supported (strong)"
    },
    {
      "id": "C6",
      "text": "The FCI separations produce scientific value over a simpler architecture.",
      "type": "explanatory/comparative",
      "evidence": "asserted only — no ablation, benchmark, or measured comparative gain",
      "support": 0.34,
      "thesis_critical": true,
      "verdict": "UNSUPPORTED — not claimed as established; the honest deficit (see audit D10)"
    }
  ]
}